9+ Unique Ice Cream Sandwich Recipes

Whether you’re looking to beat the heat or just want a unique dessert option, these are some of the best ice cream sandwich recipes with cookies to help you feel like the coolest person around (get it? Sorry, I’ll show myself out).

From double chocolate chip ice cream sandwiches to ice cream sandwiches that are actually vegan and gluten free (but don’t taste it), this is my favorite collection if cookie ice cream sandwiches.

As you dig into the recipes, you’ll discover that everyone does it a bit differently.

From slicing the ice cream in the tub to scooping it to rolling it out and freezing, there are a lot of different methods for making ice cream sandwiches and you’ll get to choose the best for you.

Kids and adults alike will fall in love with these unique flavors (as well as some old classics if you want to stick to the basics).


Pin for later!


With 9 guaranteed-delicious cookie recipes and plenty of secret baking hacks, this is your ad-free key to cookie success!

Leave this field blank

Must-Have Baking Tools (seriously)

1. Cappuccino Daim Ice Cream Sandwiches

Photo from vikalinka.com

Can I tempt you with a cappuccino daim ice cream sandwich?

Without a doubt the tastiest and the most decadent ice cream sandwich I have ever made!

2. Easy Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches

Photo from budgetdelicious.com

Kids (and grownups!) love ice cream and cookies.

Combine these two favorites and make easy ice cream cookie sandwiches that you can enjoy anytime.

3. Strawberry Brown Butter Ice Cream Sandwiches

Photo by cravingcalifornia.com

Vanilla ice cream and strawberry jam sandwiched between brown butter cookies!


The best part? This recipe is way easier to make than it looks!

I used store-bought ice cream and strawberry jam so the only technical part is making the cookies.

4. Raw Vegan Ice Cream Sandwiches

Photo from strengthandsunshine.com

A healthy homemade recipe for the classic frozen dessert!

Raw Vegan Ice Cream Sandwiches that are also gluten-free, top 8 allergy-free, and paleo!

A simple chewy tigernut flour and sunflower butter chocolate chip cookie dough, sandwiching banana nice cream!

5. Double Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches

Photo from saltandbaker.com

These double chocolate cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches are the official go-to treat for the summer!

Ultra fudgy cookies are sandwiched with vanilla ice cream and then rolled in mini chocolate chips.

They’re a kids ultimate summer treat!

6. Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookies Ice Cream Sandwiches

Photo from momdoesreviews.com

Try these Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches for a special treat !

Pick any flavor ice cream to make them just like you want them!

7. Back to School Apple Ice Cream Sandwiches

Photo from dukesandduchesses.com

These apple-themed ice cream sandwiches are a fun way to celebrate the start of school or the beginning of fall.

8. Vegan Chocolate Black Bean Ice Cream Sandwiches

Photo from rhiansrecipes.com

These Vegan Chocolate Black Bean Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches taste super decadent but are surprisingly healthy!

They’re also gluten-free and refined sugar free.

9. Gluten Free Ice Cream Sandwiches

Photo by the soccermomblog.com

You have to try this better-for-you *and* gluten free chocolate cookie ice cream sandwich.

It’s a decadent treat with half the calories of the usual store-bought cookie ice cream sandwiches!

Hey! Want more awesome dessert recipe round-ups? Check these out!

About The Author

Leave a Comment